What a SmartThings hub actually does for you — and who takes each job
A hub is not one product, it is six or seven jobs bundled into a box. Leaving a platform goes wrong when you replace the box and discover one of the jobs went missing. So here is the map.
Job one: be a Zigbee hub. This is the one that holds most SmartThings households in place, because Zigbee is where the cheap sensors live. Three alternatives here take it over directly — the Hubitat with Zigbee 3.0, the Echo Hub with Zigbee built in, and both Homeys with Zigbee 3.0. This job is comfortably replaceable.
Job two: be a Z-Wave hub. Here is where the field thins to two. The Hubitat publishes Z-Wave 800. The Homey Pro publishes Z-Wave 700. The Homey Pro mini needs the separate Homey Bridge add-on for it, and the Echo Hub has no Z-Wave at all. As above, neither does the current SmartThings hub. If this is your job, your shortlist is two products long.
Job three: be a Thread border router. The current SmartThings hardware publishes one, and so do both Homeys and the Echo Hub. Hubitat does not publish a Thread radio for the C-8 Pro, which is the one place the top pick is genuinely behind what you already own — a Thread-only Matter device will need a border router elsewhere in the house, which an Echo or a HomePod can provide.
Job four: be a Matter controller. All four picks do this, and both Homeys publish Matter v1.5 specifically. This job is a non-issue in 2026; our Matter explainer covers why, and the best Matter devices is the shopping list once you have a controller.
Job five: run the automations. This is the job that changes character rather than disappearing. Aeotec states that most automations and controls run on the SmartThings hub when the internet drops, which is a middle position. The Hubitat and both Homeys go further: their rules are evaluated on the box, full stop, and Homey publishes no subscription for control, automation or remote access. The Echo Hub goes the other way — routines are Alexa cloud routines, so an outage takes them with it.
Job six: integrate with everything via the cloud. This is SmartThings’ genuine strength and the hardest one to replace with hardware. The honest replacement is not a box on this page but a platform: Home Assistant, which integrates nearly anything including via community add-ons, bridges Alexa, Google and Apple Home, and runs fully local. It is also a hobby rather than an appliance — Hubitat vs Home Assistant is the page that weighs how much tinkering each asks for.
The two jobs nothing on this page replaces
Samsung’s own appliances and TVs. If your SmartThings setup is partly about a Samsung TV, a Samsung washing machine or a Family Hub fridge, no third-party hub here picks that up. That integration is the platform, not the radio set, and switching hubs does not bring it with you. We would rather say that at the top of the page than let you find out after the return window.
“It just works” out of the box. SmartThings is a polished consumer product with a mainstream app. The top pick on this page is explicitly not: Hubitat has a steeper learning curve, a hands-on setup, and support that is a community forum rather than a call center. The Echo Hub is the one pick here that is as easy as what you have, and it is easier precisely because it does less.
Side by side, using only what each maker publishes
Published specifications only, read from each maker's own pages and listings. The first data column is the current SmartThings hub hardware, for reference, not a pick on this page. Prices are live from the retailer and dated on each button.| Spec | Aeotec Hub 2 (SmartThings) | Hubitat C-8 Pro | Echo Hub | Homey Pro mini | Homey Pro 2026 |
|---|
| Zigbee | Zigbee 3.0 | Zigbee 3.0 | Yes | Zigbee 3.0 | Zigbee 3.0 |
|---|
| Z-Wave | No | Z-Wave 800 | No | Only with the Homey Bridge | Z-Wave 700 |
|---|
| Thread | Yes, border router | Not published | Yes | Yes, border router | Yes, border router |
|---|
| Matter | Yes | Yes | Yes | Matter v1.5 | Matter v1.5 |
|---|
| Bluetooth | For setup only | Not published | Not published | Only with the Homey Bridge | Bluetooth LE 5.0 |
|---|
| Infrared | No | No | No | Only with the Homey Bridge | Yes |
|---|
| Where automations run | Most on the hub when the internet drops, per Aeotec | On the hub | Alexa cloud | On the box | On the box |
|---|
| Network | Wi-Fi or Ethernet | Ethernet or Wi-Fi | Wi-Fi (adapter or PoE) | Gigabit Ethernet only | Wi-Fi 2.4/5GHz, Ethernet adapter sold separately |
|---|
| Apple Home | No | No | No | Yes | Yes, as a HomeKit experiment |
|---|
| Voice built in | No | No | Yes, Alexa | No | No |
|---|
| Subscription for control | None | None | None | None | None |
|---|
| Check price | | $184.76 · View on Amazon$194.955% off Price as of November 22, 2026. #ad How we’re funded | $74.99 · View on Amazon$179.9958% off Price as of November 22, 2026. #ad How we’re funded | $219.00 · View on Amazon$249.0012% off Price as of November 22, 2026. #ad How we’re funded | $399.00 · View on Amazon$449.0011% off Price as of November 22, 2026. #ad How we’re funded |
|---|
Read the Z-Wave row first and the where automations run row second. Between them they settle this page: if you need Z-Wave, it is the Hubitat or the full Homey Pro; if you only need Zigbee and want it to be effortless, it is the Echo Hub for a fraction of the money.
Why the Hubitat C-8 Pro is the one to switch to
It is the closest hardware equivalent to what people think SmartThings still is: a hub with every important radio that runs its own rules. Z-Wave 800, Zigbee 3.0 and Matter are all on board, the automations execute locally so they survive an outage, and nothing phones home for permission. There is no subscription for control or automation, and the community around it is unusually deep for a product this specialised.
The honest cons. The learning curve is steep and the setup is hands-on — this is a hub you configure, not one you unbox. There is no voice speaker, so it pairs with an Alexa or Google device rather than replacing one. And Hubitat does not publish a Thread radio for this model, so you lose the Thread border router your current hub has. Our full review is the longer version.
Why the Echo Hub is the budget alternative
Because for a large share of SmartThings households, the hub is doing exactly two things: holding some Zigbee sensors and running routines nobody wants to rebuild. The Echo Hub keeps the Zigbee, adds Thread and Matter, and gives you an 8-inch wall panel that the rest of the household will actually use — at well under half the price of the Hubitat.
The honest cons. It is Alexa-centric and much less useful outside that ecosystem, which is a genuine step down in platform neutrality from SmartThings. There is no Z-Wave. Routines run in Alexa’s cloud, so this is the one pick where you do not gain local resilience. And it wants wired power and proper mounting to look right. The Echo Hub review has the detail; the best hubs under $200 is the page if price is your main constraint.
Why the Homey Pro mini is the familiar-feeling switch
Homey is the alternative that feels most like leaving one consumer platform for another rather than for a project. The mini runs the full Homey software — including Advanced Flow and Insights — over Gigabit Ethernet, with Zigbee 3.0, a Thread border router and Matter v1.5, and it keeps automations on the box. Homey publishes no subscription for control, automation or remote access.
The honest cons. No Z-Wave, Bluetooth, infrared or 433 MHz without the separate Homey Bridge add-on, which is the upgrade path you should price before you buy. It has 1 GB of RAM, so Homey guides buyers toward roughly 20 to 25 apps. There is no Wi-Fi listed at all, so it has to sit beside a router or switch. And it was above the $200 line when we priced this page.
Why the Homey Pro 2026 is the no-compromise option
It is the only hub we cover that carries Z-Wave 700, Zigbee 3.0, a Thread border router, Matter v1.5, Bluetooth LE 5.0 and infrared in one box, with automations running on the device and updates committed until at least June 2031. For a household migrating a large mixed estate off SmartThings in one move, it is the hub that will not need a second box.
The honest cons. It is the most expensive hub in our registry by a wide margin. Its 433 MHz transmission is switched off in the US, Canada and South Korea — a radio on the spec sheet you cannot use here. There is no Ethernet port on the hub itself; Homey sells an adapter separately. And Apple Home support is published as a HomeKit experiment, with not every device feature crossing over. Our Homey Pro review and Homey Pro vs Hubitat settle the top-of-page decision.
When you should stay with SmartThings
Three cases, stated plainly because a page like this has an obvious incentive not to.
You own Samsung appliances or a Samsung TV. Nothing here replaces that integration, and it is often the actual reason the platform was chosen.
Your household is not technical and the current setup works. The top pick on this page asks more of you than what you have. A hub migration that nobody but you can operate is a downgrade for everyone else in the house.
You have no Z-Wave gear and no outage frustration. If your devices are Zigbee, Thread and Matter and your routines have never failed you, the current hardware already publishes all three radios. Switching would buy you nothing but a weekend of work.
What we left off, and why
The Home Assistant Green. It is the best functional answer to SmartThings’ cloud-integration breadth and it is not ranked here for a pricing reason: as of our last check Amazon had no listing for it in any condition, and this site does not print a price it cannot read from the dated price layer. Home Assistant publishes a $199 recommended price and lists its authorised distributors on its own Green page. The review stands, and it is named throughout this page for exactly the job it does best.
The original Aeotec Z-Wave Smart Home Hub. It is the obvious answer to the Z-Wave problem — the SmartThings hub that still spoke Z-Wave — and it no longer has a live Amazon listing. A page that recommends a product you cannot buy is not helping.
The Echo Dot. It is a Matter controller and it is cheap, and it is not a SmartThings replacement: no Zigbee, no Z-Wave. It would have made this list longer and worse.
So which one
You have Z-Wave gear or you want local rules: the Hubitat C-8 Pro. The radio set SmartThings used to have, running on your shelf.
Zigbee sensors and an Alexa house: the Echo Hub. The cheapest exit, with a wall panel as a bonus and cloud routines as the cost.
You want a polished platform, not a project: the Homey Pro mini. Full Homey software, Ethernet, local automations — price the Homey Bridge first if you need Z-Wave.
You are migrating a big mixed estate: the Homey Pro 2026. Every radio worth having, one box, nothing waiting on a cloud.